Shopify Order Tracking Apps That Actually Reduce WISMO Tickets (2026)

WISMO tickets—”Where Is My Order”—are one of the top customer service drains for Shopify stores. The right order tracking app can reduce these inquiries by 50-80% while improving customer satisfaction. But not all tracking apps are created equal. This guide compares the top options so you can choose based on your specific needs.

Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you purchase via our links. This helps support BestGrowthApps.

Why Order Tracking Apps Actually Reduce Support Tickets

Every “where is my order” ticket costs your store time and money. Beyond the direct support costs, these tickets indicate poor customer experience that can hurt retention and reviews.

The numbers don’t lie:

• Average WISMO ticket takes 5-15 minutes to resolve
• WISMO inquiries account for 20-30% of all customer service contacts
• 67% of customers check tracking at least once before delivery
• Branded tracking pages increase customer trust scores by 40%+

A good tracking app solves these problems by giving customers self-service access to accurate delivery information while keeping them in your brand ecosystem.

Top Shopify Order Tracking Apps Compared

Features That Actually Reduce WISMO Tickets

1) Multi-carrier tracking

Customers order from anywhere. Your tracking app should cover all carriers you use—and ones customers expect. AfterShip leads with 900+ carriers, while Track123 covers the major 50+ that most Shopify stores need.

2) Branded tracking pages

Generic carrier pages frustrate customers and pull them away from your brand. Branded pages keep customers in your ecosystem with your logo, colors, and can include product recommendations or cross-sell opportunities.

3) Proactive notifications

Best-in-class apps send automatic updates via email or SMS when status changes. This reduces “is my order shipped” inquiries before they happen. Look for apps with customizable trigger points.

4) Search functionality

Customers should find their order by email, order number, or name without needing login. Frictionless lookup dramatically reduces support contacts.

5) Analytics dashboard

Understanding carrier performance and delivery issues helps you negotiate better shipping rates and choose more reliable partners.

Real Pricing: What You’ll Actually Pay

Track123 Pricing

Best for: Stores wanting a balance of features and simplicity

• Free: Up to 50 tracked orders/month
• Starter: $9.99/month for 500 orders
• Growth: $29.99/month for 2,500 orders
• Scale: $49.99/month for 10,000 orders

AfterShip Pricing

Best for: High-volume international stores

• Free: 100 trackings/month (basic features)
• Essential: $9/month for 1,000 trackings
• Premium: $49/month for 10,000 trackings
• Enterprise: Custom pricing

17track Pricing

Best for: Budget-conscious small stores

• Free: Up to 100 shipments/month
• Pro: $4.99/month for 500 trackings
• Business: $14.99/month for 2,000 trackings
• Enterprise: $29.99/month for 10,000 trackings

How to Choose the Right App for Your Store

Choose Track123 if:

• You want branded tracking pages without complexity
• You need a free tier to test before committing
• You primarily ship with major carriers (UPS, FedEx, USPS, DHL)

Choose AfterShip if:

• You ship internationally with diverse carriers
• You need advanced analytics and reporting
• You’re a high-volume store (10,000+ orders/month)

Choose 17track if:

• You’re on a tight budget
• You need basic tracking without bells and whistles
• You have 500 or fewer orders per month

Choose ParcelPanel if:

• You want marketing integrations with tracking
• You’re willing to pay for premium features
• You need extensive carrier coverage

FAQs About Shopify Order Tracking Apps

Do tracking apps actually reduce WISMO tickets?

Yes. Studies show branded tracking pages and proactive notifications reduce WISMO inquiries by 50-80%. The key is choosing an app that offers the features your specific customers need.

Can I use multiple tracking apps?

Technically yes, but it’s not recommended. Multiple tracking pages can confuse customers. Choose one app that meets your needs.

Do tracking apps integrate with Shopify’s native features?

Most top apps integrate seamlessly with Shopify’s order system and checkout. Check the app’s listing for specific integration details.

What happens if a carrier isn’t supported?

Apps like AfterShip with 900+ carriers will cover most. For smaller or regional carriers, check coverage before installing or consider apps with API access for custom integrations.