ReConvert vs AfterSell (2026): Which Shopify Upsell App Should You Use?

ReConvert vs AfterSell at a glance

Upsell.com (ReConvert)

Full funnel · 4.8 ★ (2,782)

AfterSell

Post-purchase · 4.8 ★ (876)

App Store listing images, July 2026.

Both listings checked in July 2026. Order-volume tiers change; confirm your band before installing.

The price gap is the headline — until you scale

At small and mid volumes these apps are not close on price. A store taking 60 orders a month pays roughly $10 on
ReConvert and $34.99 on AfterSell for the same core job. At 400 orders a month AfterSell is still $34.99 while
ReConvert has climbed past its published $19.99 band into territory you have to look up in its full pricing table.
Somewhere in the high hundreds of orders the two cross over, and past 1,000 orders AfterSell’s $99.99 tier is
the more predictable number.

That crossover matters more than any feature comparison, because both apps do the fundamental thing well. Work out
your monthly order count first, then price both. And note the meters differ: AfterSell bands purely on orders, while
ReConvert takes the higher of order volume or upsell revenue — so a busy store with light upsell revenue is
still pushed up ReConvert’s ladder.

Where ReConvert is stronger

• Funnel coverage. Product page, cart, checkout and post-purchase in one app, rather than
  post-purchase alone — useful if you would otherwise stack two tools.
• Entry price. $4.99 versus $34.99 is a seven-fold difference for a small store.
• Depth of evidence. 2,782 reviews at 4.8 and the Built for Shopify badge, versus 876.
• Segmentation and analytics. Funnel reporting and audience segmentation are included on every paid
  tier rather than reserved for higher plans.

Where AfterSell is stronger

• Flat, predictable bands. Priced purely on order count, with no upsell-revenue meter to surprise
  you.
• A 30-day trial. Double ReConvert’s window, and long enough to gather real offer data before
  paying.
• Focus. If post-purchase is all you want, a tool built around it is simpler to run than a platform
  with four other surfaces.
• Backing. Owned by Rokt, with fee rebates available to larger stores through its network on the
  top tier.

Which should you install?

What each one actually costs at your order volume

Because the two apps meter differently, the honest answer changes with size. These are the published tiers, lined
up so you can find your own row.

Two things to take from that table. Below roughly 200 orders a month, ReConvert is not slightly cheaper, it is
several times cheaper, and for a small store that difference is most of the value. Above a few hundred orders, the
comparison stops being about price and starts being about predictability — AfterSell publishes a flat number for
each band, while ReConvert’s climbs on a table you have to go and look up.

How to test either one properly

Upsell apps are unusually easy to evaluate badly, because a good first week means very little. A few things worth
doing whichever you pick:

• Start post-purchase, not on the product page. A declined post-purchase offer cannot cost you the
  original order, so it is the only place you can experiment with no downside.
• Run one offer, not a funnel. You cannot attribute anything if you launch six offers at once.
• Give it 100+ orders before judging. Both apps include A/B testing; use it rather than trusting
  the first few days, because upsell performance is genuinely unintuitive and the offer you expect to win often
  loses.
• Check fulfilment. Place a real test order, accept the upsell, and confirm the added item lands on
  the same order and reaches your packing slip. This is where upsell apps quietly create warehouse problems.
• Diarise the trial end. ReConvert gives 14 days, AfterSell 30. Know which tier your volume puts
  you in before that date, not after.

How we compared these two

Everything below comes from the two live App Store listings, re-checked in July 2026: ratings, review counts,
published pricing tiers, stated feature sets, and merchant reviews. Where a number moves — and in this category
it moves often — the listing wins, not this page.

One thing worth saying plainly, because most comparison pages in this niche do not say it: several of the results
you will find for this search are published by companies that sell a competing app, and they do not always tell you
so. We have a commercial interest too, and it is a narrow one. We earn a commission when someone installs through a
partner link, and only one of the two apps here is a partner. So the affiliate link and the honest recommendation can
point in different directions, and where they do, we say which is which in the text rather than quietly ranking the
paying app first.

Frequently asked questions

Is ReConvert cheaper than AfterSell?

At low and mid order volumes, dramatically. ReConvert (Upsell.com) starts at $4.99 a month for up to 50 orders or $50 of upsell revenue, while AfterSell’s cheapest live-store plan is $34.99 a month covering 0-500 orders. A store doing 60 orders a month pays roughly $10 on ReConvert and $34.99 on AfterSell. The gap narrows as you scale, because ReConvert’s tiers climb with total order volume.

Do either of them have a free plan?

Not for a live store. Both offer free installation for development and partner stores only. ReConvert gives a 14-day trial on paid plans; AfterSell gives 30 days, which is the more generous window to actually test offer performance.

Which one has more features?

ReConvert covers more of the funnel: product-page recommendations and frequently-bought-together, cart upsells, checkout upsells on Plus, post-purchase one-click funnels and thank-you page offers. AfterSell concentrates on post-purchase and thank-you-page upsells with Smart Funnel AI recommendations. If you only want post-purchase, the extra surface area is not worth paying for; if you want one app running every stage, ReConvert does more.

Which is better rated?

Both average 4.8 stars, but on very different volumes: ReConvert has 2,782 reviews and the Built for Shopify badge, AfterSell has 876. ReConvert’s deeper review base is the stronger signal, though AfterSell’s are more recent relative to its size and it is owned by Rokt, an established commerce-media company.

What is the catch with ReConvert’s pricing?

Its tiers are metered on your total monthly order volume or upsell revenue, whichever is higher — and the order meter counts every order your store takes, not just orders containing an upsell. A high-volume store with modest upsell revenue still climbs the ladder. The plans shown on the listing stop at 200 orders, so look up your real volume in the full pricing table before installing; merchants who skip that step are the ones who leave surprised billing reviews.

Do I need Shopify Plus?

Only for checkout upsells — both apps restrict those to Plus. Post-purchase, thank-you page, cart and product-page offers all work on standard Shopify plans, and post-purchase is where most of the straightforward revenue is anyway, because the original order is already secured before the offer appears.

Partner links mean we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Ratings and pricing
were taken from the live App Store listings in July 2026 and change often — verify before installing.